Choose the car set for the next NSGP update!

**przemator** · 10-16-2011 08:42 PM

The next update of NSGP will feature 2011 squads and the Indian track. This poll is to decide which car set should be included as the default. Here are the possible options:

**wolfman** · 10-16-2011 08:55 PM

prz's set ver3 is ok but why everyone have blue helmets

**przemator** · 10-16-2011 09:09 PM

Originally Posted by wolfman

prz's set ver3 is ok but why everyone have blue helmets

I didn't yet bother to add correct helmets. If this option wins, I will change helmets to the correct ones.

**redmelons** · 10-16-2011 09:41 PM

I'm sure that Przemator's and Danon's designs are more detailed and up to date, but as a member of the 8% of males who have a colour vision deficiency, I find the original cars easier to distinguish when racing - which is why I've always preferred the Renault - the bright yellow stands out well. Several times I've lost places while racing because I got the cars confused and thought I was driving a car which somebody else was driving

The newer designs just look 'muddy' to me and I find them hard to tell apart. I'd actually prefer cars which were simple high-contrast block colours!

**peter-27** · 10-16-2011 11:40 PM

I want to mix and match? There are poorly designed cars in all of the four options ...

**Sida79** · 10-17-2011 06:27 AM

Poorly? Wow, you're going straight for the big guns...

I'm for Przemator set v3. In fact I'm willing to further edit it to match your desires, providing they're not artistically challenging and Przemator agrees to at least a "Przemator v3 tuned by Sida" or, preferably, Przemator v4, v5, v8 etc. C'mon, PRZEMATOR V8 sounds totally bitchin bro!

As for Paul being decision, err... vision impaired - I can sympathize but how do you see the cars if you cannot tell shades of darker/lighter? I mean, if you did there is no way you could substitute the black renault for anything else regardless of colours, on the darkness of shade alone, even in total color blindness.

**przemator** · 10-17-2011 07:21 AM

As for the poorly designed cars in my set, I\'m willing to make improvements if you tell me from which sets should I rip off the design. It\'s clear for example that I ripped off Danon\'s Renault.

@Sida: I\'m willing to do no more than a Przemator V6, out of, err... being more eco-friendly.

**peter-27** · 10-17-2011 08:50 AM

Originally Posted by przemator

As for the poorly designed cars in my set, I\'m willing to make improvements if you tell me from which sets should I rip off the design.

For your V3 set:

Mclaren: Good
Ferrari: Good
Sauber: Impressive
Renault: Not bad
Lotus: Dreadful

(The original is the most accurate)
Toro Rosso: Fine
Red Bull: Brilliant
Williams: Could be better (Your first set representation is best)
Force India: Okay (Danon's is best, although without the wierd shadow on the front wing)
Mercedes: Okay (Prefer Danon's, notice he has the mini Petronas green splodge on the monocouge)
Virgin: Okay (Could be improved, the red should go a bit further back, past the drivers helmet)
Hispania: Okay (Danon's is better)

**Sida79** · 10-17-2011 12:17 PM

Originally Posted by peter-27

For your V3 set:
Sauber: Impressive

Disagree. The red/black line on the Sauber nose is just decoration and is not very visible even in the full size car, and it's the red that catches eye more anyway. The red part on the front spoiler is 50% space at most and the darker line simulating the shark fin is too dark to simulate a smooth transition in ehight. If you look at Danon's Sauber each of the mentioned things is represented closer to the truth. The thin red lines are a touch of brilliance as they are almost invisible on a small car and even has that red blob on the nose, even if positioned wrongly. Other than the sharpness of your car Danon's Sauber is a lot more like Sauber!

Lotus: Dreadful

(The original is the most accurate)

I don't see how.

Williams: Could be better (Your first set representation is best)

Latest williams i best in several aspects: it looks most like the actual williams. It has improvements in the shape of the nose, front wing, and the little blue touch on the side pods as well as the blue lines. I'd only opt to move out the blue middle line and replace it with a 3d simulation of a white shark fin in the form of a gray line as seen on Danon's Sauber.

Force India: Okay (Danon's is best, although without the wierd shadow on the front wing)

Danon's has a nice touch with that degree'd line on the nose but has an outdated rear spoiler and the colours are less Force India-like, although these could be tweaked a bit as well. The shark fin-gray fits nicely.

Mercedes: Okay (Prefer Danon's, notice he has the mini Petronas green splodge on the monocouge)

The spludge is a nice touch but Danon's teal is more off, as well as the rear wing.

Virgin: Okay (Could be improved, the red should go a bit further back, past the drivers helmet)

Agree.

Hispania: Okay (Danon's is better)

Danon's is more realistic due to crazy shading reminiscent of the actual car.

**Alfonso** · 10-17-2011 04:55 PM

Well, i would like a combination of Danon´s and Prz V3 but i think its not possible i guess.

Prz´s Force India is brilliant for me. Sauber also very nice and mercedes also.
From Dannon´s the hispania is simply fantastic cause it has some sort of shade/blend that gives a 3D sensation.

Agreed about the red stuff on the Virgin also.

So, if i have to vote now i would go for Prz V3 but honestly would like to see a V4 with small improvements, rear wing a bit (only a bit) larger for example and some color combinations also. The rear wings could have a stripe like the mercedes from Dannons, it kind of gives a nice look. Confusing? Hope not.

**Sida79** · 10-17-2011 09:50 PM

Ah, so you are the one who causes confusion!

Danon's cars are great but a lot of little things have changed on the cars in the meantime (<- Prz :*), such as Mercedes' rear wing. Rest assured all we'll be looked into...

**Alfonso** · 10-17-2011 10:05 PM

Originally Posted by Sida79

Ah, so you are the one who causes confusion!

Danon's cars are great but a lot of little things have changed on the cars in the meantime (<- Prz :*), such as Mercedes' rear wing. Rest assured all we'll be looked into...

Guilty of charge!

**peter-27** · 10-17-2011 10:54 PM

So this has estabilished we all want different things :p

**Sida79** · 10-18-2011 06:30 AM

It has? You wrote what you think and I explained how "looks more like the current car" has more priority than "Peter likes that version better" simply because the former might satisfy more people than the latter. However, any suggestion that is not directly opposing that one is perfectly valid

**peter-27** · 10-18-2011 11:43 AM

Originally Posted by Sida79

It has? You wrote what you think and I explained how "looks more like the current car" has more priority than "Peter likes that version better" simply because the former might satisfy more people than the latter. However, any suggestion that is not directly opposing that one is perfectly valid

I went for accuracy too Srdjan.